TALKING CARS WITH CONSUMER REPORTS #76: TESLA MODEL S P85D: FINAL TEST RESULTS

EV Channels Review

Consumer Reports has concluded its testing of the Tesla Model S P85D, awarding it a perfect score of 100, a first for the publication. This exceptional rating is attributed to the vehicle's groundbreaking performance, including its astonishing acceleration and surprising energy efficiency, which effectively 'broke' their established rating scale. However, the review emphasizes that a perfect score does not equate to a perfect car. Significant drawbacks include a steep $127,820 price tag and interior fitments that don't quite match the luxury expected at this price point. Range anxiety, while reduced compared to other EVs, remains a concern for long road trips if not utilizing Tesla's Supercharger network. The P85D's performance, particularly its instant, overwhelming acceleration, is described as a unique experience, akin to a G-force sensation, but also potentially disorienting and not necessarily a practical advantage for everyday driving. While the P85D offers supercar-level performance in a family sedan package, the reviewers suggest that for most consumers, a standard Model S or other less expensive vehicles might be a more sensible choice, prioritizing personal connection with the car over extreme, albeit impressive, performance metrics.