TALKING CARS WITH CONSUMER REPORTS #112: KIA NIRO AND BMW 5 SERIES

EV Channels Review

Consumer Reports' 'Talking Cars' episode #112 delves into two new additions to their test fleet: the 2017 Kia Niro and the redesigned BMW 5 Series. The Niro, positioned as a hybrid competitor to the Toyota Prius, is noted for its more conventional crossover-like styling and a driving experience that's considered more enjoyable than the Prius, with better steering feel and a more substantial feel. However, its EPA-estimated fuel economy (43-50 MPG combined) falls slightly short of the Prius's 52 MPG, and its FWD-only configuration limits its appeal in snowy regions. The reviewers question its ability to significantly disrupt the Prius's market dominance, despite a lower starting price. The BMW 5 Series, specifically the 530i xDrive, is examined for its shift to a turbocharged 4-cylinder engine. While praised for its quietness, smooth ride, responsive transmission, and decent performance that maintains a premium feel, the reviewers note the engine sound can be gruff and diesel-like from the outside. A significant point of contention is the optional nature of advanced safety features like forward collision warning and automatic emergency braking, which are considered essential and should be standard on a vehicle in this price range. The episode also addresses a viewer question about replacing a Toyota Tundra, with the hosts strongly recommending the Honda Ridgeline for its comfort and suitability for commuting and light-duty use, advising against over-speccing a vehicle with capabilities one doesn't need.