Streamed from the official YouTube channel Auto Expert John Cadogan .
ELECTRIC FIRE TRUCK FAIL - AFTER COSTING TAXPAYERS MILLIONS
Auto Expert John Cadogan
Content Quality Score
EV Channels Review
This video critically examines the ACT government's procurement of a plug-in hybrid electric fire truck, labeling it a 'net zero ideology fiasco' and an 'operability disaster.' The reviewer highlights that the truck, costing $1.6 million (significantly more than a conventional diesel equivalent), has been inoperable for 83% of its life, amounting to only 137 days of service over nearly two years. A fully electric logistics support truck, costing nearly $2 million, has also reportedly never been in service. The core criticism is that these expensive, unreliable vehicles are a result of bureaucratic ideology rather than evidence-based decision-making, failing to prioritize the primary function of emergency services: saving lives and property. The reviewer contrasts this with the proven reliability and significant emission reductions of modern diesel engines, questioning the real-world benefit and cost-effectiveness of the current electrification push in emergency services.
Vehicle Specs
| Brand | Rosenbauer |
|---|---|
| Model | Fire Truck |
| Trim | Plug-in Hybrid |