EV VS INTERNAL COMBUSTION - 10 YEAR CO2 SHOOTOUT! I RAN THE NUMBERS

EV Channels Review

John Cadogan critically examines the environmental impact of Electric Vehicles (EVs) versus internal combustion engine (ICE) cars, specifically comparing a Tesla Model Y Performance to a Mazda 2 GT over a 10-year ownership period. His analysis focuses on CO2 emissions, factoring in manufacturing (especially battery production for the EV) and operational energy sources. Cadogan argues that EVs are not inherently superior for climate action, citing the significant CO2 cost of battery production and the reliance on grid electricity, which in Australia is largely coal-fired. He contends that smaller, more affordable ICE cars like the Mazda 2 offer a more accessible and potentially greener solution for the average consumer when considering the total lifecycle CO2 emissions and the opportunity cost of purchasing a much more expensive EV. The review highlights the importance of considering real-world usage, charging habits, and the accessibility of solutions for the broader population, concluding that incentivizing smaller ICE vehicles could be a more effective climate strategy than mandating expensive EVs.