BMW I5 VS. 530I: WHICH ONE SHOULD YOU BUY IN 2024?

EV Channels Review

This video pits the all-new 2024 BMW i5 eDrive40 against the 2024 BMW 530i, exploring which is the better buy. While both are rear-wheel-drive sedans, the i5 offers 335 horsepower from its electric drivetrain, compared to the 530i's 255 horsepower from a 2.0L turbo-four. The 530i is significantly lighter (around 1,000 lbs less), which the reviewer notes allows for more traditional BMW driving fun and a lower price point (approximately $9,000 cheaper). However, the i5's instant electric torque provides superior acceleration, especially out of corners, and a more composed, dynamic feel, attributed partly to its lower center of gravity from the battery pack. The reviewers ultimately favor the i5 eDrive40 for its exhilarating performance and driving dynamics, despite its higher cost and weight, concluding that the 530i feels more like a commuter car with a noticeable lack of low-end torque, making it suitable for those prioritizing long-distance travel without charging concerns or budget limitations.