BEST LUXURY COMPACT SUVS: TESLA MODEL Y VS. BMW X3 M, MERCEDES-AMG GLC 63, ALFA STELVIO QUADRIFOGLIO

EV Channels Review

This Edmunds video pits the Tesla Model Y Performance against three high-performance luxury compact SUVs: the Alfa Romeo Stelvio Quadrifoglio, BMW X3 M Competition, and Mercedes-AMG GLC 63 S Coupe. Despite the pandemic disrupting a traditional comparison, the reviewers highlight key differences. The Model Y stands out for its blistering, immediate acceleration and strong performance-per-dollar value, though its interior is deemed plain and its reliance on phone-based interaction and lack of Apple CarPlay/Android Auto are noted drawbacks. The Stelvio Quadrifoglio impresses with its Ferrari-derived V6, sound, and handling, but its brake-by-wire system and less premium switchgear are criticized. The X3 M Competition offers immense power, practicality, and track-ready handling, but its ride is consistently firm, even in comfort mode. The GLC 63 S Coupe delivers V8 torque and a decadent interior but feels heavy and less agile, with its coupe styling impacting visibility. Ultimately, the Model Y offers unmatched acceleration for its price, while the German rivals provide more traditional luxury and engagement, albeit at a significantly higher cost.