SMART #3 VS MINI ACEMAN: A SURPRISE RESULT!

EV Channels Review

In this head-to-head, the smart #3 'Premium' and the MINI John Cooper Works Aceman are pitted against each other. The smart #3 is praised for its superior range (283 miles WLTP), larger battery (66 kWh), faster acceleration, and more mature, spacious interior, feeling akin to a Mercedes. It offers better practicality with more storage, a larger boot, and a more comfortable ride, making it the sensible choice for 95% of journeys. The MINI Aceman, while lauded for its fun, go-kart-like driving dynamics and cheeky character, is criticized for its shorter range (214 miles WLTP), smaller battery, less practical interior with limited storage, and a firmer ride. Despite the Aceman's engaging driving experience, the smart #3's overall competence, comfort, and practicality lead it to be declared the winner by the reviewer for everyday use, though the reviewer notes that top-spec versions of both cars may not represent the best value, especially with potential luxury car tax implications.